The New Matthew’s Anime Blog

Winter Season Review Part 1: Minamike Okaeri, CLANNAD after story, Asu no Yoichi!

Yes, I’ve been slacking off as usual, and that isn’t likely to change soon since that’s my natural state (^^;; Anyways, thought I’d go through the shows that ended recently and give a quickie review on each. I really don’t like giving out number ratings and such, but in this case I’ll do it based on this blogger survey at Game ya anime ni tsuite bosoboso to kataru hito which rates shows on the following six categories on a 1-5 scale (for a total of 30 points max): Story, Characters, Visual, Direction, Music, and Overall.

Minamike Okaeri

Story: 4
A move back closer to the feel of the first season of Minamike which makes up for what happened to Minamike Okawari. Respected the original manga, and the original parts were entertaining as well.

Characters: 5
Easily 5 for the lovable cast of characters… well, I don’t know if you’d call Hosaka lovable, but just his presence onscreen made me laugh. I was glad to see that Touma got some more screentime this season. Her stupid brothers, especially Natsuki, were funny as well. However, my favorite’s Uchida (then Chiaki).

Visual: 3
The one disappointing part of the show as the animation quality from Asreed was simply good enough most of the time. Naoto Hosoda’s part in episode 12 gets a 5+, though (his Uchida is much too cute). I’m sure Shinpei Tomooka would’ve done a better job in the B part of that episode if the schedule weren’t as rough as it seemed.

Direction: 3
Stayed true to the feel of the original manga, though rather average for the most part with nothing really standing out to me.

Music: 4
Excellent OP/ED, good music in show kept from previous seasons.

Overall: 4
I’m very satisfied with how it turned out. Hoping for another season after more stock of the manga is built up.

Total: 23

---

CLANNAD after story

Story: 4.5
“CLANNAD is life”, as a 2channeler once said, going farther than those other galge that simply end after high school. Engrossing from beginning to end. A bit off for the somewhat complicated “true” ending involving parallel timelines.

Characters: 5
Easily a 5. Tomoya’s growth from beginning to end was quite pronounced and shown well. Sanae-san and Akki were always amusing in some way. Heroines were all attractive in their own ways. I favor Fuko (which is probably no surprise to most of you). And, Ushio-chan kawaii yo Ushio-chan.

Visual: 5
It’s KyoAni. Just everyday work for them.

Direction: 5
It’s KyoAni. Just everyd(ry Had to reach for the kleenex more than once through the last few episodes.

Music: 5
Excellent OP/ED, and music (as expected from a Key game).

Overall: 5
Yes, I’m a Key fan, I bought the AIR and Kanon DVDs and will grab CLANNAD as well. Easily recommended for those that liked those previous works. I could grab the PSP version of CLANNAD, but I doubt I’d be able to get all the way through it (^^;;

Total: 29.5

---

Asu no Yoichi!

Story: 3
A good adaptation of the well-worn harem genre that’s pretty faithful to the original (that I quickly scanned). Good mix of comedy and not too serious seriousness.

Characters: 4
Yes, Asu no Yoichi!’s characters are pretty much the usual stock characters for this genre, but since they were well used, no problems. Wassan was especially entertaining. Wishing that Kagome-chan got more time in the spotlight.

Visual: 4
High quality animation every episode as is required for this genre (if the heroines aren’t cute, who would watch?). Good job, AIC.

Direction: 3
The usual for the genre, but solid nonetheless.

Music: 3
Nothing that stood out that much to me, but plenty good enough.

Overall: 4
I looked forward to watching every week. I have absolutely no problem with shows that aren’t “innovative” so long as they execute well.

Total: 21

Tags: Asu no Yoichi!, CLANNAD, CLANNAD after story, Minamike, Minamike Okaeri, Winter 2009